allison ✒️ hat Uncanny Valley Girls von Zefyr Lisowski besprochen
Memoir more than horror
2,0 stars
I struggled with this book. I suppose I imagined this differently, where a horror movie/element would be the main point of an essay, and some personal thoughts or stories or arguments would be added. Lisowski does this, but this book goes further into memoir than essays about horror. So, I guess I was disappointed at first, but I didn't like what I got even though I tried to switch gears. I thought the forced connections from personal stories to horror movies were, well, ridiculous in places.
There's a section where she talks about racist tendencies in movies about drowning where it's only white people who usually drown, who "get to" drown, and how it's a peaceful death versus violent ones. Then immediately follows this with how she (a white woman) feels like she's drowning metaphorically. She talks about many metaphorical applications of water. Then she seems to remember what …
I struggled with this book. I suppose I imagined this differently, where a horror movie/element would be the main point of an essay, and some personal thoughts or stories or arguments would be added. Lisowski does this, but this book goes further into memoir than essays about horror. So, I guess I was disappointed at first, but I didn't like what I got even though I tried to switch gears. I thought the forced connections from personal stories to horror movies were, well, ridiculous in places.
There's a section where she talks about racist tendencies in movies about drowning where it's only white people who usually drown, who "get to" drown, and how it's a peaceful death versus violent ones. Then immediately follows this with how she (a white woman) feels like she's drowning metaphorically. She talks about many metaphorical applications of water. Then she seems to remember what her point was and mentions lynchings, and then goes back to the metaphor. It was like whiplash.
Every essay has wild examples of this, where it would just stretch so far away from the original point of the essay, then snap back all of a sudden. I only finished reading it because it was for a book club. I don't like to waste reading time on books I don't enjoy.