Reviews and Comments

Herr Rau

herr_rau@leselog.de

Beigetreten 3 Tage, 12 Stunden her

This link opens in a pop-up window

G. K. Chesterton: Manalive (Paperback, Book Jungle) 3 stars

A wind sprang high in the west, like a wave of unreasonable happiness, and tore …

Review of 'Manalive' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

The enigmatic villain of The Man Who Was Thursday, the curious puzzle solutions of The Club of Queer Trades, but less dynamic than either, less frantic and hilarious action. Still, good.

The easily-guessed plot twist and some of the characterization reminded me of Ray Bradbury's story "The Best of All Possible Worlds", and Curt Goetz's play "Hokuspokus" - both younger works, though in Goetz's case only by a good dozen years.

Sarah L. Caudwell: Thus was Adonis murdered (2012, Robinson) 4 stars

When her personal copy of the current Finance Act is found a few metres away …

Review of 'Thus was Adonis murdered' on 'Goodreads'

4 stars

Very entertaining. If the characters weren't so charmingly Wodehouselike, you might call them frightful yuppies in the making. Still, they are very very funny.

The story is told in an intriguing and effective way; most of the characters are far away from the scene of the crime, they (and we) learn about developments via the postal service and the electric telephone, and the temporal offset of these various forms of communication is used very satisfyingly. One of the main characters we never meet in person.

Not long after the middle of the novel we are told by the garrulous yet curiously distant narrator that now all the necessary information to solve the crime has been presented, although the narrator at that point hadn't made the connections. Both of which is neat. Unfortunately, the solution itself at the end is rather far-fetched, and something of a letdown. But then, you don't …

John Gregory Betancourt: Pulp Classics (Paperback, Wildside Press) 2 stars

Review of 'Pulp Classics' on 'Goodreads'

2 stars

It's what it is, so you might as well give it four stars instead of two. Eight stories from the weird menace pulp subgenre, albeit in a mild version - there are some really nasty stories in other magazines.

Eight stories, each with a man-woman couple, newly married or starting on their relationship. All the women have "soft feminine breasts [which] were like tired kittens sleepily stirring for a caress."

In nearly all of the stories, the protagonists encounter a strange building, often while vacationing - a sanitarium, spooky old house, old family mansion, magician's abode. (Ultimately the roots for the Rocky Horror SHow plot?) In one of the stories the location is a modern apartment in a modern city, in another an exotic island, in a third the new family house.

All but two stories end happily, with the male rescuing the female from danger (usually of a sexual …

Blake Snyder: Save the Cat (2005) 3 stars

Review of 'Save the Cat' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

An interesting read. Some of it is repetitive, the book might be shorter without much loss - lots of inspirational paragrapgs repeating the message of each chapter at the end of each chapter.
I don't know much about screenwriting (having read only William Goldman's books, which touch on the subject), but this book seems to be full of useful, concrete advice. Advice, that is, how to write a screenplay that you can successfully sell. Not good screenplays necessarily, and not with an eye towards good films, just things you will be able to sell, apparently, written according to formula. True, formulaic films can be good or bad, and I prefer them good, but they all sound very predictable and there are so many films that are more interesting.

Aleks Scholz, Kathrin Passig: Handbuch für Zeitreisende (Hardcover, German language, 2020, Rowohlt Berlin) 5 stars

Review of 'Handbuch für Zeitreisende' on 'Goodreads'

4 stars

Ein schönes Buch – eine Art Sammelsurium mit Rahmenhandlung. Die Rahmenhandlung ist aber wichtig: Es gibt Zeitreisen, jetzt, in unserer Gegenwart; aber noch nicht sehr lange. Und dieser Reiseführer gibt Tipps dazu und erklärt uns hinterrücks dabei viel über unsere Welt, unsere Vorstellungen, die Vergangenheit, und wie sehr viel mit sehr vielem zusammenhängt und die Dinge nicht so einfach sind, wie man denkt.

Besonders schön ist der Anhang, in dem Leseempfehlungen gegeben werden, aus denen ich mich bereits bedient habe. Außerdem wird darin das Konzept von Zeitreisen, das dem Buch zugrunde liegt, ein wenig genauer erklärt, und dem galt schon während der Lektüre mein Interesse, auch wenn das sicher kein Schwerpunkt des Buches ist. Also: Man kann in die Zeit zurückreisen, und zwar in die Vergangenheit der eigenen Welt, ändert aber eigentlich gleich mit dem Ankommen diese Vergangenheit und damit auch die Zukunft und befindet sich damit in einer Parallelwelt. …